Investing in financial markets requires careful selection of funds. When done wisely, it can lead to rewarding returns and long-term financial growth. Two of the most popular passive investment options are Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) and Index Funds. Both these funds help investors gain diversified exposure to markets at a low cost. However, they have different features which may affect your investment strategy.
Continue reading this guide to understand the difference between ETF vs index fund, their benefits, drawbacks, major differences, and which is a better option.
Understanding Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)
An Exchange-traded Fund is a collection of securities or pooled investments that track and replicate a specific index, commodity, sector, or market. The assets that an ETF can invest in include stocks, bonds, commodities, currencies, etc. Moreover, ETFs can be traded at real-time prices throughout market hours, so their prices keep changing.
Benefits of Investing in ETFs
ETFs are a good way to build a diversified portfolio at a low cost. Here are some more advantages of investing in ETFs:
-
Liquidity and Flexibility
High liquidity is one of the biggest benefits of investing in an ETF. As an investor, you can trade these funds throughout market hours like individual stocks. This way, investors can buy and sell these funds anytime to rebalance their portfolios instantly.
-
Affordability
ETFs are inexpensive investment tools. Many ETFs have a cost ratio much lower than that of most mutual funds. Investors can purchase one unit of an ETF, which generally does not require a lot of capital, so people with small amounts of cash to spare can invest. Because of their affordability, investors can easily invest in diversified portfolios with limited capital.
-
Diversification
ETFs offer immediate diversification by replicating an index, sectors, or commodity. Instead of purchasing many stocks individually, an investor can achieve broad exposure to the market using a single ETF. For instance, the Nifty 50 ETF provides access to 50 individual companies, thus reducing the risk of owning one stock. Such features make ETFs beneficial for risk management.
-
Accessibility
ETFs are widely available through brokerage accounts and online trading platforms, making them easily accessible to investors. Comparing ETF vs index funds, index funds require higher minimum initial investments, allowing fewer individuals to participate in the stock market.
-
Tax Advantage
Compared to traditional mutual funds, ETFs have more tax benefits. This is because underlying securities are sold in case the investors redeem their investments, resulting in a tax burden for the fund and lowered gains. However, in the case of ETFs, there is less internal trading that does not give rise to capital gains and, thus, less tax liability.
Drawbacks of ETFs
While ETFs can be a beneficial investment option for many, there are certain drawbacks associated with it. Here are the key drawbacks of investing in ETFs:
-
Trading Costs
If you frequently buy or sell ETFs, it can increase your trading costs despite having a lower expense ratio. Subsequently, you will have to pay commissions, bid-ask spreads, and brokerage fees, which can reduce your overall returns if you make frequent transactions.
-
Price Fluctuations and Market Volatility
Unlike mutual funds, which are priced only once daily, ETFs trade during the day. Therefore, their prices are sensitive to market demand and supply. As a result, ETFs can trade at a premium or discount compared to their NAV. This way, there can be potential losses for a short-term trader.
-
Lower Dividend Yield
Some ETFs may offer lower dividend yield than individual stocks or actively managed funds. Since ETFs track an index rather than prioritise dividend income, they may not be ideal for investors seeking high dividend payouts.
Understanding Index Funds
An index fund is a type of mutual fund that aims to replicate the performance of a specific market index. It is a passively managed fund because the fund managers do not pick and choose individual stocks. Instead, they imitate the holdings of the particular index. This makes index funds a low-cost and long-term investment.
Benefits of Investing in Index Funds
There are many benefits to investing in an index fund, which is not readily available in many actively managed funds. Here are the different advantages of investing in index funds:
-
Avoidance of Fund Manager Bias
Being a passive investment fund, index funds are unaffected by the decisions of fund managers. Compared to actively managed funds, fund managers of index funds simply replicate the portfolio composition of its index. This takes away any biased opinions or mistakes in making decisions regarding fund management.
-
Lower Fund Management Costs
Since index funds track a defined index instead of requiring active stock selection, they have much lower expense ratios than actively managed funds. Moreover, investors pay less in management fees because the portfolio managers rebalance the holdings only when the underlying index changes. This cost efficiency maximises returns over the long term.
-
Low Concentration Risk
Index funds offer sufficient diversification by spreading investments across different sectors. This way, it is possible to reduce the impact of any one stock’s poor performance by reducing the concentration risk.
Drawbacks of Index Funds
Taking a closer look, it is observed that index funds have many drawbacks as well. Here are some of the major drawbacks of index funds:
-
Absence of Direct Investor Control
The index fund investors cannot decide the types of stocks and sectors they should have exposure to. Therefore, they need to accept all holdings, including underperforming stocks. Unlike actively managed funds, index fund investors cannot exclude specific stocks or industries. This can be unappealing to those who want an investment tailored for them.
-
Lacking Sufficient Downside Management
One of the primary disadvantages of index funds is their inability to respond to market declines. Since they track a predetermined index, they do not withdraw their holdings in a bear market or economic downturn. In contrast, actively managed funds will liquidate or shift to defensive assets or boost cash holdings to cut losses.
-
No Room for Alpha
Index funds do not try to beat the market, instead, they try to replicate an index. This means investors will not get returns above the market average. Those seeking to beat the market returns may prefer actively managed funds where skilled fund managers apply their skills to beat the benchmark index.
Major Differences between ETF vs Index Fund
While both ETFs vs index funds aim to provide diversified, passive investment strategies, they differ in how they are traded, managed, and structured. Here are the major differences between ETFs vs index funds:
| Feature | ETFs | Index Funds |
| Trading Mechanism | Traded like stocks throughout the day | Bought and sold at NAV calculated once per day at market close |
| Liquidity | Highly liquid, can be bought and sold anytime during market hours | Less liquid, transactions are processed at the end of the trading day |
| Minimum Investment | No minimum investment; investors can buy a single unit at market price | May require a minimum investment amount depending on the fund house |
| Expenses | Generally lower than index funds | Slightly higher due to management fees |
| Tax Efficiency | More tax efficient because of the in-kind redemption process | Less tax-efficient as fund managers may need to sell holdings to cover redemptions |
Which is a Better Option: Index Funds vs ETFs?
Choosing between index funds vs ETFs requires you to consider factors like investment goals, risk appetite and trading patterns and strategies. Both ETFs and index funds have become popular in the Indian financial market. Both of these investment vehicles offer a diversified portfolio and lower risks from a passive investment strategy.
If you want the flexibility of real-time trading and seek tax efficiency for large investments, investing in ETFs is a good option. Also, if you are comfortable managing trading costs, investing in an ETF should be your preference.
If you want to avoid brokerage fees and prefer a long-term approach, index funds are where you will want to put your funds. Index funds also allow you to invest through an SIP which streamlines and balances your investments.
Index fund vs ETF is always debatable, depending on the individual’s investment preferences. Both these investment funds provide excellent diversification and low costs. Therefore, understanding the difference between index funds and ETFs will help you make an informed decision.
Final Words
In conclusion, both ETFs and index funds serve similar investment purposes but cater to different investment needs and risk appetite. If you prefer trading and better tax efficiency, ETFs are a valuable option. Whereas, if you are a passive investor who wants simplicity in your investment approach, index funds are better. The ETF and index fund differences and suitability depend on how actively you want to manage your investments.
